I think it slows down discussion of tools considerably that some sort of form isn’t used as the basis for the post.
To me, it seems like there are too many times that tool suggestions are created where the original poster has no clue what the criteria is or if the tool they are proposing meets it.
I think having user fill out a form for their suggestions, will prompt users to be more diligent about their proposals. This will create more effective suggestions.
As an example, the form could be something as simple as…
Name and url of tool:
Reason to add/remove tool:
how does the tool meet or not meet the criteria listed on PG (please provide relevant sources):