The current way of displaying the criteria for a recommendation is to list it within its relevant tool page, e.g., VPN criteria within the VPN page. I think this is okay as is, but I believe a better way would be to make a new criteria page that lists the various criteria for different tools and have each relevant tool page’s criteria section hyperlinked to that criteria page.
There are currently 4 tools that have a criteria for being recommended, them being:
I understand that most recommendations do not have a set criteria for certain reasons. Browsers, for example, have many benchmarks that need to be analyzed and discussed in a large conversation and therefore its criteria cannot be listed so easily.
However, there are other tools that have an implicit/inferred criteria which I think should be written out and added to the criteria page, them being:
I think we would benefit from this, that being that people are now able to readily read and understand all the criteria we have for certain tools. An instance where this would be helpful is if and when someone wants to suggest a tool that has a criteria.
It may also especially help out newcomers of the privacy community, new readers of Privacy Guides, and those who have been misguided by internet echo chambers and unreviewed user content from forums/blogs. By understanding what criteria there are for certain tools, they are able to create a baseline for what a tool that respects and maintains your privacy and security should look like, which would hopefully reduce the net sum of mis/disinformation in the privacy community.