I do not know if the method you are proposing works, since ultimatley you’d be paying with BTC. That being said, even if it does work, it’s a very convoluted process. It’s not Proton supporting user friendly anonymous payments with no restrictions, which is what many of us want, it’s circumventing Proton’s limitations and it requires technical skills that most people may not have, including myself.
BTC that is obtained through Monero and only used for one purpose is inheriting Moneros privacy.
Yes, best would be if Proton supports Monero and other private payment options
Which technical skills are you lacking that would be required to use a swap service?
I’ll try to address both of these at the same time since they are related.
BUYING CRYTOCURRENCY ANONYMOUSLY IS NOT EASY FOR A NEWBIE
I have personally never bought any cryptocurrencies. The Monero that I currently have I got through a friend. That friend bought the Monero for me, and I gave them cash in exchange.
The reason I have never bought cryptocurrencies is because most crypto exchanges require KYC. Same for crypto wallets if you are going to buy through them. The exchange my friend bought Monero from has their ID and their credit card info.
Now, I understand that it’s possible to buy cryptocurrencies anonymously via P2P exchanges. However, that presents its own challenges.
- It’s hard to find people that sell small amounts ($30-$60)
- Small amounts are likely to be expensive and might not be worth it.
- Your identity is likely to be exposed to the seller you buy from.
From what I’ve seen, the most common payment methods for P2P exchanges are bank transfers and PayPal, which both expose your ID.
There is the possibility to meet the seller and pay them cash or deposit cash via ATM to the seller’s bank account, which can be completely anonymous.
That being said, both methods above require that the buyer and the seller be in the same country, which dramatically narrows your pool of sellers. This is why, IMO, cryptocurrencies don’t really remove international barriers like some people claim, because you will always have more options if you live in a rich country like the United States than if you live, say, in Vietnam.
I understand that the challenges I presented above exist even if Proton directly accepts Monero. But buying BTC adds more complications.
I know that there are cryptocurrency ATMs where I live, but they don’t sell Monero. I have never tried them, so I don’t know if I would be able to buy BTC with just cash or if I’d be forced to use a credit card, which would identify me.
Does anybody here have experience with crypto ATMs?
IMHO, if I can deposit cash into someone’s bank account via ATM without exposing my identity, I should be able to buy cryptocurrencies via ATM the same way.
BITCOIN IS NOT ANONYMOUS BY DEFAULT
Suppose I have $200 USD in BTC that a friend gifted me. My wallet is not linked to any ID.
Because BTC is not anonymous by default, if I buy a Proton subscription with it, it can still be traced back to my wallet, even if my identity isn’t directly exposed. And the history of my purchase is recorded on a public ledger. That’s not the case with Monero. @azure_raven’s solution may provide some layer of protection, but still not as much as Monero.
PROTON GIFT CARDS IN THE PROXY STORE IS THE BEST SOLUTION
When I ask Proton to support anonymous payments, I am not just considering myself but everyone, including the average user who doesn’t really understand cryptocurrencies. Right now, I still rely on my friend to acquire them.
This is why I think the easiest way for Proton to support anonymous payments is by selling their gift cards on the Proxy store. The Proxy Store accepts cash and Monero, and on top of that, they are one layer removed. It’s the solution that serves everyone, the average user, as well as the tech nerd.
You would have the same problem with any crypto currency, as yourself mentioned also with Monero.
But that doesn’t prevent you from anonymizing it after you bought it.
Directly accepting Lightning and Monero would be best, but in the mean time:
- Get Monero
- Make a few transactions to yourself to accumulate decoys
- Swap the exact amount to Bitcoin
- Pay service that accepts Bitcoin Mainet but nothing else.
Or
- Get Bitcoin
- Deposit into a Cashu/Fedi mint (which gives you Zero knowledge proofs for your bitcoin)
- Make transactions with it, preferably in Lightning, but you can also pay to on chain addresses
My solution should keep you anonymous, assuming you can also acquire the XMR anonymously
Usually a fiat CEX using LTC
LTC <> XMR swap (via CAKE for example)
You can add an extra step here and hop XMR to a different wallet
XMR <> BTC swap via a Tor supported intermediary. Your XMR goes into the ether, BTC appears from a random wallet into Proton.
•••
I don’t think this is trivial – I agree with you there. I merely highlight that is in fact possible, even if it is not easy
EDIT: If Proton were to do anything LTC MWEB is the most user friendly solution and is sufficiently privacy preserving, although, perhaps slightly imperfect relative to XMR. There’s a privacy/utility tradeoff here
Mailbox.org supports encrypted inbox with regular PGP and YOUR keys, in any normal mail program. Also cash payments and they made their own, FOSS, self-hostable e2ee videocall tool OpenTalk.
Apart from that no e2e encrypted services which is unfortunate. Still
Apart from that no e2e encrypted services which is unfortunate. Still
I guess Posteo.de has the same options in regard to cash and encryption. They also believe they can keep online payments anonymous somehow, in the sense that the payment isn’t bound to the account.
