Surfshark VPN vs. Proton VPN for Hiding VPN Usage

A person is currently using Surfshark VPN with OpenVPN and the NoBorders feature. I’ve heard that using OpenVPN with Surfshark should, in theory, make it difficult for websites to detect that he is using a VPN (it’s their “camuflage mode”). However, I’ve noticed that some websites still recognize that he is using a VPN. Is this a problem with Surfshark, or is there something else going on?

Additionally, would Proton VPN be better for hiding the fact that he is using a VPN?

Thank you.

Other apps/websites/entities have many ways to learn that you are using a VPN. To me, this is not an issue unless they are blocking access to them via VPNs - in which case most times I simply avoid using the website/service/what have you as me being on VPN is more important. But this is a personal decision.

Surfshark is not a recommended VPN service you should use. Proton, IVPN, and Mullvad are the ones highly recommended.

ProtonVPN + Stealth Mode should provide you closest to what you’re looking for as far as I know. And yes, Proton would be significantly better to use.

4 Likes

It is going to be difficult if not impossible to answer this with certainty and objectively. But I would imagine Proton + Stealth mode is better as Proton itself is far superior than Surfshark.

From you are you trying the fact that you use a VPN?
Afaik camouflage mode and stealth do no try to achieve this but rather to hide this from your isp !

Exactly, none of these features are designed to prevent websites from knowing you are using a VPN. The way they do that is by recognising that your IP address belongs to a known VPN provider. The only way around this is for VPN providers to maintain large swaths of servers, frequently rotate IP addresses, and minimise malicious use of their IPs.

Exactly. I’d still only recommend Proton VPN for trust reasons.

1 Like

One option could be to pick a vpn provider whose IPs are least likely to not be on the “VPN providers” list (one that uses residential IPs maybe?) and use your secure, primary VPN provider chained with such provider. This way you retain privacy but sacrifice latency and cost. And of course it might be complex to set up, you likely have to have the primary VPN set at router level and this probably won’t work on mobile outside of that.

You can’t hide that you are using your VPN. The simple fact that you route your requests to a different IP will make it clear you are using a VPN.

What you might want is something censorship-resistant, in which case I would recommend Mullvad.

1 Like

Windscribe VPN provides a residential IP. Which means you get a non VPN IP that is not blocked by any services, websites. However that feature costs almost twice as much as Mullvad or Proton VPN.

Why do you want to hide the fact that you are using a VPN? This is the most important thing.

in that case i think a residential proxy from a reputable service would likely work and not flagged

also big tech vpn unlikey to be blocked. eg cloudflare warp or apple relay.
connect to a trusted vpn first and tunnel it to those big tech vpn

At the end of the day, if you want the privacy benefits of VPNs, you have to accept the cons. And because VPNs group hundred/thousand users traffic together, one of them is going to be malicious.

Your best bet is probably a VPN providers that advertise streaming servers.