Does any of what you said go against the criteria as currently constructed? No.
Should we be removing a tool based on criteria that has not been approved? No.
It seems like this is a cart before the horse conversation. People seem to want to remove 1Password based on a set of criteria that is not used yet. Go get that approved and then revist this.
Get this criteria approved, then lets revisit this. For now, thats irrelevant. This is a thread to remove 1Password, not to change the criteria. Please see