Quad9’s withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine

Cloudflare’s statement on the Quad9 case:

As Quad9 put it:

Quad9 and Cloudflare, and others face similar challenges in France and other parts of Europe. Misguided attempts by rightsholders and the courts are causing significant harm to citizens, and unless things change soon we are on the path to a fragmented and less-secure internet because of what seems to be a lack of technical understanding of how public DNS resolvers can provide service.

Cloudflare has written an excellent summary of their (and our) position

2 Likes

Practical takeaways:

  1. After Nov 24 Quad9 becomes unavailable to French users. It can be replaced by 3 other resolvers recommended by PG: Cloudflare, Control D, AdGuard.

  2. Quad9 encourages French citizens to take action:

French citizens: tell your legislators that looking up names is not a criminal offense… We know there are potential plans in consideration in France (and other European nations) to give private corporations and others automated and unvalidated abilities to filter DNS content that they alone determine to be unwanted, making it possible for a wide range of badly-managed or anti-democratic activities to be implemented.

ARCOM is your regulatory authority, and you should tell them this precedent places France at risk both from a practical and strategic perspective.

You can donate here to help us continue to deliver on our mission and assist us in the legal costs we incur in this and other fights.

1 Like