First, very very very few people use Gentoo. Second, simply linking to this page doesn’t do anything or explain things to people. Third, how is the average person to install and set up SearXNG? That’s what I was asking and encouraging you to explain.
Source code will be made available to customers who have been paying for at least 12 months. You will have to sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) and a non-compete agreement (NCA) to access the source code. You will be able to self-host and use it for yourself and your family (personal use), but not distribute it or use it for commercial purposes, without our permission.
I find this very interesting, especially with respect to the NDA and its content in this specific scenario. Let’s say I pay for 12 months, plan to self-host, but then review the source code and find something quite alarming from a privacy perspective. With a signed NDA, depending on the exact wording, I might not be able to blow the whistle (unless it involves unlawful activities).
I appreciate the efforts and fully understand the developer’s wish to protect his product. However, without being able to see the NDA or source code for 12 months, I would, however, be cautious regarding privacy claims (despite appearing to use Mojeek under the hood). Furthermore, while the account generation methodology is applaudable, if I change my account every month, would I still be able to review the source code and self-host after 12 months? The FAQs (or anywhere else) do not address this.
I’ll review the privacy policy, in detail, later when time permits. However, if I sign an NDA and non-compete, then they would be storing personal data. Ergo, the FAQ “What personal data do you store?” is currently misleading.
These are really legal/corporate issues rather than product critiques. I might give the IOS app a try
Yeah the fact that this is what they say itself is a huge red flag and I am immediately discounting this service. They appear to be a little too elitist and almost narcissistic to have such views.
Can you clarify on what specifically is “a huge red flag” for you in the FAQ? I’m not trying to change your point of view, just trying to understand it and potentially clarify things a bit, there.
Wow, thank you for this very valuable insight. We have not yet drafted the NDA or the NCA (because no one’s been paying for Uruky for more than 3 months now), but we will have a lawyer draft this with us in a few months. The NDA will focus on disclosing the source code, not bugs or security/privacy issues. This is to prevent someone from obtaining the source code, pasting it somewhere else, and claiming no responsibility for another entity taking it.
You’re right that if you sign an NDA, we’ll have more information about you, and I’d love for your opinion on ways around that. If you never sign it, we never get it. Also, it won’t be stored in the database or even same server, which is an important distinction.
The 12 months is verifiable only from the creation timestamp and expiration timestamp (which is extended when you top-up), so as long as there are more than 12 months between those two dates, you can request a copy of the source code and get it (you won’t get direct and 24h access to the repo).
While we use Mojeek as a search provider, we also support 4 other search providers (stated and up-to-date in the FAQ, like EUSP from Qwant/Ecosia).
I hope these make sense and we’re open to privacy improvements that don’t compromise our business viability.
Hello, Uruky co-founder here. I can’t answer for others, but I’ve used SearXNG before and it didn’t work for me because it was slower and didn’t exclude domains I didn’t want results for (like Instagram’s, Facebook’s, or Pinterest’s). I also couldn’t boost some domains I prefer results for (like Wikipedia’s), or specifically easily choose certain engines/providers for specific queries.
That being said, SearXNG is a great non-big tech alternative, and you can even define it as a fallback engine in Uruky!