NextDNS logging is opt-out, not opt-in as stated on PG's DNS Resolvers recommendations page

[jonah (Jonah Aragon)]

@BionicBison

Has the team come to a consensus that NextDNS should be removed until they clarify their privacy policy?

No, @dngray is looking to get in touch with them first.

@BionicBison

If so, why was it removed from the table only to be re-added under the new cloud filtering section?

It was removed from the table for a reason unrelated to this discussion in a PR I authored last November:

Split DNS recommendations into secure/non-filtering providers, and filtering/SaaS providers

Continuing the discussion from How is a NextDNS account private?: We could probably split our recommendations between: Cloudflare Quad9 Mullvad and AdGuard Control D NextDNS The latter 3 with their account-based controls are kind of an entirely separate type of service compared to the first three, they’re more like a cloud-hosted Pi-hole, and we should probably explain that distinction more clearly. This is also kind of related to the problem this person had: