I’m also curious to know why some topics are unlisted/locked, then silently deleted. Won’t list any here [1] but I do have a hard time understanding how they’re making a mess as a whole, given the amount of overall traffic on this forum. Leaving some of those locked will just feel more transparent …

I feel as the feedback here has been clear, and we have started down a path of people repeating themselves and their points, rather than adding anything new. This is really hindering our ability to take in this feedback and discuss it amongst ourselves, so I’m going to close this thread. Thanks eve…

I think everything you said basically makes sense, but I should clarify (if only for the purpose of making sure the feedback I provided is as useful to you as possible) that I was told that the reason for the silencing was the flags, not any replies. If that is not correct, then at minimum the expla…

Just popping in to say that I have also found thread deletion to feel heavy handed at times, and have seen users quickly recreate essentially the same thread within a few days either because they could not find their original thread, or because they had the same/similar question as the OP of a delet…

I can understand deleting entire threads where discussion of illegal activity or violations of user right to be forgotten is occurring, however using deleting whole threads (not just singular posts) in places where the violations are more minor can lead to confusion amongst users, and uncertainty r…

This was why I contacted the mods. We did not get to any point of agreeing - no, which is even some of the worst things, a mod itself was objectively violating their own rules - and so the whole thing got locked after overall six messages. I am completely OK with deleting the all-known deleted topi…

[image] kissu: Concerning point tho is the fact that @jonah reacted by proposing OP to just create a blog to avoid such issues in the future. I do not disagree with people hosting their own blog/socials , yet it looks like a weird thing to say to somebody on a forum. I read the thread you sh…

[image] ThePrivacyDad: and was pretty shocked by this reply from Jonah. I, frankly, still do not follow how someone can post: title: Do you guys use whonix? raw: Let’s have a good conversation about it and see how poor it became in recent years. I feel pity for those whose it for their ano…

This place is the sanest online privacy community I have ever been into where people actually know how to communicate, answer questions, and engage in healthy discussions. I have learned a lot since I started participating, and I hope this discussion will resolve in the best way possible. -a regula…

[image] phnx: It also seems to me that a lot of complaints basically come down to thinking unlisted posts demonstrate a lack of transparency, but I don’t know how else we can be expected to remove posts which violate the rules. Hey there, I would simply suggest to communicate more on your int…

It was simply a third party tool supported by the platform. It allows automatic “announcement" of moderation actions done via that tool to a dedicated channel. Be it automatic triggers or manual actions. IIRC the format was something like: {ACTIONTYPE} DATE: {YYYY-MM-DD} TIME: {HH:mm:ss} MODERA…

Forum Moderation

Meta

Expert4870 March 9, 2026, 10:01pm 25

I don’t think stuff should be deleted unless it is graphic or illegal/unethical. Even if someone is spreading FUD or being disruptive, I’d rather see their account locked with maybe a message implying what happened. It is more transparent and allows other users to decide their own opinions, with all the knowledge of the conversation. There can definitely be exceptions to this, just a general feeling I have.

Topic		Replies	Views
Question Regarding Forum Moderation Transparency and Feedback Meta other	46	1916	June 2, 2026
Missing thread Meta discourse	12	500	November 18, 2025
Cannot reply to a thread about my project, my reply goes in moderation then dissapears Meta discourse , other	13	404	August 22, 2026
Question regarding tool suggestion policy General	4	358	January 23, 2024
State of this forum, better moderation Meta discourse , other	23	1580	October 2, 2024

Forum Moderation

Related topics