The Hated One's Proton saga continue

Well, THO is absolutely right about Proton. I’ve felt the same way for a while, and I’ve been wanting to leave them for some time now. Proton is a closed ecosystem, like Google, but paid-for, and it seems more focused on making a profit than pursuing its core mission.

Proton has become a company that’s constantly trying to bring out new, pointless products to compete with every open-source service. Seriously, what is Proton thinking, wanting to launch a browser, an messenger and a Proton phone?

Proton lost my trust a long time ago, and they deserve to fail. More serious players will take their place.

Just because I say I don’t need fast development doesn’t mean I want slow development.

I don’t understand what you mean by this.

Why sadly? I’d prefer them to actually be getting paid and hopefully passionate about they do.

They’ve demonstrated that they have fairly talented developers, I’m sure they would be able figure something out to allow using passchain or authnkey for passkey 2fa, and same goes for notifications. Are you saying they’re not capable of it?

I never said it wasn’t secure… yet. It does make me quite worried though that they’re apparently putting out 90% ai generated code and possibly neglecting pen-testing.

I think we’re arguing about different things here, or moving the goal post. I’m not saying they shouldn’t support stuff like android or chromium. What I am saying is that if they’re really committed to be a big tech alternative they wouldn’t require google dependencies for relatively basic functions like 2fa or notifications. This doesn’t mean developing a whole entire ecosystem, there are already alternatives like unified push, they just need to actually support them.

1 Like

I never said I was against using ai to find bugs and security vulnerabilities.

I do have a problem with 90% ai generated code and possibly not being properly reviewed. I’m doing my best to take both what was said in the articles and what Proton said with a grain a salt but I feel it’s best to err on the side of them possibly skipping some pen-testing for the sake of speed.

This is how I feel about Proton currently.

Pretty much this. I’m not even really sure how they could expect to support a phone operating system if they still need FCM for notifications and play services for passkey 2fa.

2 Likes

Are we talking about Proton, or THO, or both here? I’m confused.

Alright bro.

Multiple senior Proton engineers came forward after the 404 Media article to clarify that the situation had been presented without important context. Penetration testing had never been abandoned. From what those engineers said, additional penetration testing was approved and implemented. Not only that, they’ve said themselves they weren’t cutting back, they were even expanding it.

4 Likes

No idea what kind of stuff he posts on Patreon, but apparently he’s doing better than 99% of OnlyFans creators.

I really wonder how many people here actually watched the video before commenting on it. I personally agree with almost all of what he said, except around the 7 min mark when he shows some bechmark where the top model is GPT-5.4. Current models are infinitely better than 5.4 so his argument that “ai doesnt make secure code” needs a lot more elaboration and evidence.

His argument that proton engineers are being told to use ai to write code faster and spend less time auditing and not be “losers” is legit tho, cuz if they keep making code with ai without spending enough time to understand it, eventually they’ll reach a point where their own codebase is a black box to their own engineers. But by that time ai will be even better, so it might just compensate for that, who knows. Plus, the code is open source so it can be verified independantly, it’s not like u have to trust em they didn’t fuck up smth, at least on the client-side.

Also, his videos are funny. When i make my mum watch privacyguides videos, she gets bored and loses interest fast, she says she doesnt understand what they’re talking about and doesn’t care that much (she’s not tech savvy but works with photoshop and excel all day). But when she watches The Hated Ones videos she generally doesnt get bored as fast cuz he uses funny memes and his voice is like funny. So he has a much bigger audience, whereas PG is prob only watched by privacy nerds.

3 Likes

One thing to note. “Big Tech” is not just associated with evil, but is in fact the proxy term now for “large malicious digital technology organisation”.

There’s a lot of words in the English language and reducing debates to such trivial comparisons is what erodes all important nuance.

Proton definitely has some of the features of a large technology organisation. But it might just be because businesses have figured out how to do business well… Organisational structure, development cycles, etc. The devil is always in the detail. Proton has an aim to be a tech-suite replacement. That doesn’t mean it is “big-tech” in the pejorative sense.

I think you may have missed the word “afford”. You’re asking them to do more expensive development than they planned. So how do you know they can afford it?

So you’re saying that putting out 90% AI-generated code is a security concern. How?

possibly neglecting pen-testing.

How many pen tests were neglected? Has the number increased recently, or decreased? 404 Media reported one pen test being postponed. Was it the first time in Proton’s history that they postponed a test? Do they postpone tests more often now than a year ago? The article says nothing about this.

You can’t develop for a platform without being dependent on that platform. Passkeys on Android use Google Play Services: you either use Play Services, or microG, or reimplement OS core things on your own, effectively rewriting parts of the OS. Same goes for notifications.

So again, you’re asking Proton to do more than other software developers and at the same time to not use tools that help to develop faster.

Does anyone have a more nuanced view on his criticism of how data is encrypted with Lumo?

I can’t discern whether it’s still more private and secure to use it or just duckai since the latter doesn’t require an account