Will the recent Proton news (AI hysteria, toxic workplace, perception over security) affect recommendations?

Not sure about calling the whistleblowers cowards to weigh in on that. Some of the other devs speaking out now might have given context to it and, maybe I can understand why they’re angry. The workplace conspiracy theories, I don’t have an information on. But at this point, if someone told me 404 Media had an axe to grind against Proton, I wouldn’t accuse them of being the kind of person who pets a dog that isn’t there.

A lot of the other issues have since been clarified. And for what it’s worth, more Proton developers have spoken out about the article, with those who were quoted in it, saying their comments were misrepresented. As far as I can tell they haven’t bothered posting about it on Reddit, and I can probably guess why. Regardless of what they say, they’re likely going to get demolished there anyway.

After going through the additional information and hearing from the employees themselves, my opinion has changed quite a bit. Not sure if Andy is the most pleasant boss to work next to, and I can’t give him a free pass. The more information that comes out, the more this looks like Reddit wants an evacuation because somebody smelled smoke from a barbecue.

At this point I’d be happy to see the following plot twist:

Proton devs on Reddit start saying that when they leaked data to 404 Media, they used Proton Mail for it. Meaning Proton is so secure that even Proton can’t find out who leaked the data through its own email. And then one dev gets fired: he goes to Reddit and mentions he used Tuta to send the audio recordings to 404 Media.

Meanwhile, I can’t help feeling satisfied seeing devs comment to confirm things I speculated about before. Like:

well..

Hi. Proton employee here, I was even famously quoted in the 404 media article.

I have spent a long-ass time debunking 404’s misinfo about Proton online, like “Proton helps the FBI”.

I would be wary about believing every single thing written by 404 about Proton.

[1]


  1. source: Making sure you're not a bot! ↩︎

I’ve always had alternatives ready. One of the reasons I use my own domain and luckily had a MXRoute lifetime account created from way back so I can just host there if needed.

I’m all for all the quotes, but it’d be nice to see the entire messages instead of hand picked quotes. I’m not saying that it isn’t factual, but it’s still nice having the context to make more informed decisions.

Agreed. This event has made me a bit more skeptical about both Proton and 404 Media

Honestly, it’s something I expect to see on places like reddit but not here…usually

For one of the points made in this thread there is a screenshot of the internal email used by Proton’s leadership: Proton To ‘Re-Interview’ Staff About AI To See Who Gets To Keep Their Job - #2 by jordan

I have an MXRoute lifetime as well I picked up (5GB only), but it’s a completely different use case, not even close functionality wise.

True for sure. But for me it’s one of the best options beyond rolling my own (which from everything I’ve read sounds like a PITA) for control over my email.

Encryption not withstanding.

We have fairly strict rules on that around here, because otherwise threads deteriote into conspiracy rubbish and advertising targets - usually by competitor sock puppets or users trying to validate their decisions.

This post isn’t even that bad, as I said above the public does not have access to employee performance metrics, so he may very well have identified a real issue. We can’t know either way. The comment about better documentation is rather funny because that’s a known technique devs use to ensure their irreplaceability.

I do think to some extent this follows a similar vein to some of the “AI outrage” we’ve seen, eg employees of large corps going to the media to complain about “AI is gonna take over the world”, because they are/were about to be fired anyway.

True, that was my point as well: devs using security as an excuse to move slower

I’m not sure that Proton’s stance here is any different than any other tech company right now. I am a software developer at a big tech company. I haven’t written a line of code in months - not because I don’t want to - but because leadership wants us to move fast. These frontier models write code much more quickly than I do but I still need to review and understand the code, and then I put my changes up in a PR and it is reviewed by more frontier model bots AND one or more humans. Then we still test (and possibly revert, if necessary) changes. So I think as long as there are tests and good software practices put in place around AI, that commercial companies (including Proton) can still push out quality material. The issue will be when humans are taken out of the feedback loop or deemed unnecessary due to AI’s capabilities. It might not be that the product becomes insecure or lacking in privacy, but there will definitely be ethical concerns. But in terms of privacy - I’m not sure that their (Proton’s) use of AI means that their product(s) cannot be recommended here.

Although, I would like to say that while I use AI in my work/professional “life”, I value things that have more human involvement when I’m deciding to follow/subscribe/purchase something. So, for me personally, Proton’s shift to such heavy AI usage is discouraging. I fully believe that we have to vote with our dollar on the issues that are important to us, so I might decide not to continue my subscription(s). The issue is that there isn’t one alternative and splitting across services, although recommended, is much more costly than Proton Unlimited.