# macOS

**URL:** https://discuss.privacyguides.net/t/macos/23466
**Category:** Tool Suggestions
**Tags:** rejected
**Created:** 2024-12-26T09:43:21Z
**Posts:** 38

## Post 1 by @anon48875053 — 2024-12-26T09:43:21Z

### Check this box to affirm you have no conflict of interest.

on

### Website

> **[OS - macOS Tahoe](https://www.apple.com/os/macos/)**
>
> macOS Tahoe with a new design, more ways to work seamlessly across devices, and new features to turbocharge productivity every day.

### Short description

macOS is an operating system designed by Apple for its Mac computers. It is a Unix-based system that provides a user-friendly interface, integrating seamlessly with other Apple devices and services.

### Why I think this tool should be added

Considering that 1Password is still recommended because PG doesn’t really care that much about FOSS, I don’t see why macOS couldn’t be recommended.

macOS is a lot better than Windows, and sometimes it can even be better than Linux. It has the best security out of all three and also has the ability to have the best privacy from 3rd parties because of proper sandboxing.

The UI/UX is also miles better than Windows and most Linux distributions.

### Section on Privacy Guides

Desktop/PC

---

## Post 2 by @Breeze7846 — 2024-12-26T09:46:02Z

Apple tried to have image scanners on all apple phones earlier this year.

We can’t audit their security practice due to the proprietary nature.

This seems like an argument to remove 1password instead of approving MacOS.

As such, I don’t think this is in line with PG ethos

---

## Post 3 by @fria — 2024-12-26T10:03:44Z

> [@Breeze7846](#):
>
> Apple tried to have image scanners on all apple phones earlier this year.

Do you have a source on that. I don’t remember hearing about that at all.

---

## Post 4 by @fria — 2024-12-26T10:05:28Z

I’m not really sure this is necessary, we already have a macOS guide. The Linux distros are recommended because there’s so many different options if you need Linux, whereas there’s only one macOS. There are so many reasons someone might need a specific operating system outside of just the privacy and security features that it makes more sense just to give info about how to lock it down than to recommend one over another.

---

## Post 5 by @Breeze7846 — 2024-12-26T10:07:08Z

Hey. Have a source. Sorry, I guess this happened a bit further back than I remember (2021), but this does prove it happened. Ars Technical has a LOT more articles on this if you want to read up

> **[Amid backlash, Apple will change photo-scanning plan but won’t drop it...](https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/09/apple-promises-to-change-iphone-photo-scanning-plans-to-address-criticisms/)**
>
> Apple issues vague statement promising “improvements” but still plans to scan photos.

---

## Post 6 by @fria — 2024-12-26T10:07:50Z

Yeah that’s the one I remember. Still it was never implemented so it doesn’t really factor in.

---

## Post 7 by @Breeze7846 — 2024-12-26T10:09:03Z

No, but they sure darn tried. They were quite stubborn on it for a while as I recall. Doesn’t exactly fill me with confidence in apple

---

## Post 8 by @anon48875053 — 2024-12-26T10:16:46Z

It still didn’t happen.

---

## Post 9 by @Breeze7846 — 2024-12-26T10:23:39Z

We wouldn’t be so forgiving of a FOSS organization, or Proton, if they pulled a stunt like that

---

## Post 10 by @fria — 2024-12-26T10:31:57Z

I think we would. Remember the Amazon Ubuntu thing where they would send all your searches to Amazon?

> **[Richard Stallman Talks About Ubuntu](https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=Sw3BCuFU81cnyCg3&t=89&v=CP8CNp-vksc&feature=youtu.be)**
>
> Subscribe to our weekly newsletter: https://www.tfir.io/dnlBecome a patron of this channel: https://www.patreon.com/TFIRFollow us on Twitter: https://twitter...

And that was actually implemented.

---

## Post 12 by @anon80779245 — 2024-12-26T12:02:06Z

> [@fria](#):
>
> I think we would. Remember the Amazon Ubuntu thing where they would send all your searches to Amazon?

PG never recommended Ubuntu.

---

## Post 13 by @fria — 2024-12-26T12:14:31Z

Just giving another example. I don’t think them previously having something like that would be grounds to not recommend it.

---

## Post 14 by @anon80779245 — 2024-12-26T12:36:03Z

Are we talking about the same Apple?  
The same apple that:

- Remove VPNs, messaging apps from it’s App Store, at Russian And Chinese requests without any push-back (in those countries) [source1](https://applecensorship.com/news/apple-tightens-censorship-of-vpn-apps-in-russias-app-store)[https://applecensorship.com/news/apple-must-end-its-unquestioning-compliance-with-cac-orders](https://source2) [source3](https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/29/apple-removes-vpn-apps-from-the-app-store-in-china/)
- Wants to make sideloading on mac extremely difficult, if not impossible [source](https://hackaday.com/2024/11/01/apple-forces-the-signing-of-applications-in-macos-sequoia-15-1/)
- Was fined by French DPA for privacy violations [source](https://techcrunch.com/2023/01/05/apple-app-store-ad-targeting-eprivacy-breach/)
- mandates an Apple ID for it’s iPhone, and it’s Mac App Store [source1](https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7138048?sortBy=rank) [source2](https://l.opnxng.com/r/MacOS/comments/14mpcg4/download_macos_apps_from_app_store_without_apple/)
- getting an app notarised requires paying 99$ for dev plan [source](https://forums.developer.apple.com/forums/thread/121113)

---

## Post 15 by @fria — 2024-12-26T12:51:25Z

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> Remove VPNs, messaging apps from it’s App Store, at Russian And Chinese requests without any push-back (in those countries) [source1](https://applecensorship.com/news/apple-tightens-censorship-of-vpn-apps-in-russias-app-store)[https://applecensorship.com/news/apple-must-end-its-unquestioning-compliance-with-cac-orders](https://source2) [source3](https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/29/apple-removes-vpn-apps-from-the-app-store-in-china/)

They really have no choice, they have to comply with the local laws.

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> Wants to make sideloading on mac extremely difficult, if not impossible [source](https://hackaday.com/2024/11/01/apple-forces-the-signing-of-applications-in-macos-sequoia-15-1/)

This was a bug in gatekeeper not anything intentional it was just misreported. Gatekeeper is easy to disable anyway, there are no plans for them to disable side loading on Macs.

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> Was fined by French DPA for privacy violations [source](https://techcrunch.com/2023/01/05/apple-app-store-ad-targeting-eprivacy-breach/)

Looks like it’s just within the App Store which you can avoid on a Mac if you want. You also have a toggle for personalized ads it’s just enabled by default.

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> mandates an Apple ID for it’s iPhone, and it’s Mac App Store [source1](https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7138048?sortBy=rank) [source2](https://l.opnxng.com/r/MacOS/comments/14mpcg4/download_macos_apps_from_app_store_without_apple/)

It’s mandatory to install new apps from the App Store but it’s not mandatory to use an iPhone, it’s just that you can’t sideload in the US for now.

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> getting an app notarised requires paying 99$ for dev plan [source](https://forums.developer.apple.com/forums/thread/121113)

Doesn’t seem relevant to privacy or security, other stores charge to get in them as well.

---

## Post 16 by @asanyan — 2024-12-26T13:00:58Z

Wasn’t Apple also caught not respecting people’s privacy settings? Just a bug?

---

## Post 17 by @fria — 2024-12-26T13:02:57Z

No basically there was a setting in the settings for telemetry or something but it didn’t cover all Apple apps which confused people.

---

## Post 18 by @anon80779245 — 2024-12-26T13:03:33Z

> [@fria](#):
>
> They really have no choice, they have to comply with the local laws.

That’s not true. Google choose to stand up to Russia (after some PR backlash, true) by reverting it’s removal of anti-war videos.  
Yes, they got banned for it. and that’s the right thing to do.

---

## Post 19 by @TheG — 2024-12-26T13:03:49Z

The code to scan images still exists on iphones, it is just not used.

---

## Post 20 by @fria — 2024-12-26T13:04:18Z

Do you have a source for that?

---

## Post 21 by @anon80779245 — 2024-12-26T13:04:26Z

> [@fria](#):
>
> No basically there was a setting in the settings for telemetry or something but it didn’t cover all Apple apps which confused people.

They enabled telemetry for targeted ads by default

> CNIL found that v14.6 of iOS automatically read identifiers on the user’s iPhone — which served a number of purposes, including powering personalizing ads on the App Store — and that processing occurred without Apple obtaining proper consent, in the regulator’s view, as consent was being gathered via a setting that was prechecked by default. (NB: 2019 [CNIL guidance on the ePrivacy Directive](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/jorf/id/JORFTEXT000038783337) stipulates that consent is necessary for ad tracking.)

---

## Post 22 by @fria — 2024-12-26T13:04:52Z

> [@anon80779245](#):
>
> They enabled telemtry for targeted ads by default

Yes I thought you were referring to a different incident.

---

## Post 23 by @anon80779245 — 2024-12-26T13:06:20Z

> [@fria](#):
>
> Looks like it’s just within the App Store which you can avoid on a Mac if you want. You also have a toggle for personalized ads it’s just enabled by default.

IMO Yes. An OS is perhaps the most sensitive software, so we need to be very careful about what we recommend. Trust is paramount.

---

## Post 24 by @anon29374801 — 2024-12-26T13:42:13Z

> [@anon48875053](#):
>
> Considering that 1Password is still recommended because PG doesn’t really care that much about FOSS, I don’t see why macOS couldn’t be recommended.

The 1Password issue lives in your head rent free. :joy:

This makes me question whether this is a good faith suggestion or just another [joke post.](https://discuss.privacyguides.net/t/nordpass-password-managers/22705)

---

## Post 25 by @anon21489307 — 2024-12-26T13:57:09Z

I don’t think recommending an OS that, sometimes, didn’t respect the users’ privacy toggle is a good idea in a privacy-focus community like this one.

---

## Post 26 by @anon36940904 — 2024-12-26T14:09:40Z

What exactly are you referring to here?

---

## Post 27 by @anon21489307 — 2024-12-26T15:10:55Z

> **[Bypassing macOS TCC User Privacy Protections By Accident and Design -...](https://www.sentinelone.com/labs/bypassing-macos-tcc-user-privacy-protections-by-accident-and-design/)**
>
> TCC is meant to protect user data from unauthorized access, but design flaws mean users and malware can bypass TCC, even by accident.

> Any application that can control the Finder (listed in ‘Automation’ in the Privacy pane) also has Full Disk Access, although you will see _ **neither** _ the Finder nor the controlling app listed in the Full Disk Access pane.

> Because of this complication, administrators must be aware that even if they never grant FDA permissions, or even if they lock down Full Disk Access (perhaps via MDM solution), simply allowing an application to control the Finder in the ‘Automation’ pane will bypass those restrictions.

I don’t know whether this is fixed.

* * *

Apple in general have 1 issue regarding privacy. They use privacy as a selling point in their marketing. But that’s only true against 3rd parties, not them. You can see privacy issues in many of Apple’s 1st party products, e.g. iCloud that’s integrated in macOS that even with the encryption and advanced data protection enabled, not all data is end-to-end encrypted, including emails, calendar events, contacts, and file metadata. And there are Siri, etc.

---

## Post 28 by @Valynor — 2024-12-26T16:19:17Z

Apple clearly states on their support site what is encrypted:

> **[iCloud data security overview – Apple Support (UK)](https://support.apple.com/en-gb/102651)**
>
> iCloud uses strong security methods, employs strict policies to protect your information and leads the industry in using privacy-preserving security technologies, such as end-to-end encryption for your data.

---

## Post 30 by @fria — 2024-12-26T19:38:02Z

Well that’s not the case on macOS, only iOS. macOS allows side loading.

---

## Post 32 by @fria — 2024-12-26T19:54:14Z

I don’t really understand. I’m sure google, Microsoft, and any Linux distro would remove software from their repo under legal threat. The App Store is equivalent to a Linux distro’s first party software repo essentially.

They could absolutely target a specific windows user’s Microsoft account as well it’s no different.

---

## Post 33 by @jordan — 2024-12-27T07:27:27Z

The suggestion is to add macOS though, iCloud is a seperate product and is entirely optional on macOS.

---

## Post 34 by @anon50731736 — 2024-12-27T08:03:36Z

There are a lot of strawman fallacies (and the horn effect) here. Using iCloud and/or App Store is entirely optional in macOS. It’s good to talk about their privacy implications but not in this situation. Also, when we examine Apple’s privacy policies, we should only examine parts that are related to macOS.

There’s one thing that I think no one has mentioned. You cannot just _download_ macOS like Windows and Linux distros. Sure, hackintosh exists, but it breaks the chain of trust that Apple built for macOS. So, when we recommend macOS, we essentially recommend buying Mac computers.

On the other hand, you can say that we recommend buying Pixel phones by recommending GrapheneOS. And we **do** recommend Pixel phones in the hardware section.

What I want to say is recommending macOS but not mac computers makes no sense.

PS: We lack hardware recommendation for laptops and desktops. If we do add them, I think it’s reasonable to mention laptops and desktops separately. Some people, due to their scenario, can’t use desktops.

> **Off-topic**
>
> Apple Silicon Mac computers + Asahi Linux is a very fine combo from a privacy perspective.

---

## Post 35 by @crossroads — 2024-12-27T08:29:18Z

> [@anon50731736](#):
>
> Using iCloud and/or **App Store** is entirely optional in macOS

How common is distribution of programs outside of App Store? I know that most of opensource ones provide .dmg files, but what about proprietary and commercial programs?

---

## Post 36 by @anon50731736 — 2024-12-27T08:39:59Z

It’s very common. In fact, I think it’s the de-facto way to get popular software on macOS. Looking at [our recommendations for desktop browsers](https://www.privacyguides.org/en/desktop-browsers/), all of them can **only** be downloaded directly from the source. You won’t find Mullvad, Firefox, and Brave in the App Store.

Popular proprietary software like Chrome and Adobe Suite can only be downloaded directly from the source. For Office 365, you can choose between the App Store version and the… Microsoft… version? What I mean is that the way Office 365 handles updates is different between the two.

PS: I think it should be noted that platforms like [brew](https://brew.sh/) exist on macOS.

---

## Post 37 by @anon50731736 — 2024-12-27T08:54:00Z

I just checked [our standards for desktop OSes](https://www.privacyguides.org/en/desktop/#criteria). There are two criteria that macOS fails:

> - Free and open source.
> - Supports a wide variety of hardware.

@anon48875053 wants us to reevaluate the former. Even then, I think macOS still fails because of the latter. Maybe we can split them into minimum standards and ideal standards. We do this a lot, after all.

PS: It’s not uncommon for us to encourage/discourage users from doing something regarding a specific recommendation. This fact is crucial if we reevaluate our standards and add macOS to the mix. For example, with Fedora Atomic Desktops, we note:

> Fedora Atomic Desktops come in a variety of flavors depending on the desktop environment you prefer. As with the recommendation to avoid X11 in our criteria for Linux distributions, we recommend avoiding flavors that support only the legacy X11 window system.

---

## Post 38 by @fria — 2024-12-27T11:27:57Z

> [@fria](#):
>
> I’m not really sure this is necessary, we already have a macOS guide. The Linux distros are recommended because there’s so many different options if you need Linux, whereas there’s only one macOS. There are so many reasons someone might need a specific operating system outside of just the privacy and security features that it makes more sense just to give info about how to lock it down than to recommend one over another.

I think I laid it out pretty well here. People use an operating system for a lot of reasons outside of just which one is the most secure, they might not even have a choice. With something like email they all do basically the same thing, but that’s not really the case here. So it makes more sense to have guides on major operating systems that people use rather than recommendations. Plus it doesn’t meet our current criteria as was pointed out already and I don’t really want to weaken the criteria here.

Since macOS objectively doesn’t meet our current criteria I’m marking it rejected for now.

---

## Post 39 by @dngray — 2024-12-28T08:26:49Z


