Is there risk of using anonymous prepaid phone for bank 2FA?

I’m a beginner-tech-knowledge person in the US with many privacy concerns.
Until now, I’ve been still using a landline for two factor authentication with banks by receiving an automated call for telephone banking (no aps). Within two months, they are shutting down the landline and I need to transition all banking 2FA to a cell phone. I want to use a cell phone only for 2FA that doesn’t track me and isn’t connected to everything else I do. I also don’t want the cell number to be associated with me publicly available on the internet if I can help it. I’d like to keep it as private as possible and only use for banking.

I do already have an anonymous active cell phone line used for emergencies that I could give them for 2FA, but I’m wondering if I give anonymous cell number to banks, are there any issues which may come up? such as needing to ID verify myself (if sim swapped or something), which likely wouldn’t be possible with the anonymous cell phone and then would I be locked out of my banks?
Or is there a way to get a new cell line, but try to keep it out of the internet data sites that would associate the number with me. (also want to be as SIM swap proof as possible, so want to factor in that security issue too)

I know this isn’t written well, but I have to act fast as they are closing the landline very soon.

Is TOTP (i.e., a 2FA app) or a FIDO security key (i.e., a YubiKey) an option?

If SMS is the only option, I suggest seeing if a Google Voice number would work (it does for me with my banks). A Google Voice number is much less succeptible to a SIM swap attack than a regular carrier number. You can also secure that particular Google account with a security key.

I have a specific Google Voice number I use for SMS 2FA whenever possible, and nothing else. I no longer have any high-value accounts (financial or otherwise) that rely on a carrier number for SMS 2FA.

Then you phone number would not be anonymous anymore becuase the bank knows it and can link it to your identiy

Do you give out a separate number if you expect them to call you?

Like for a financial institution, do you give them both your Google Voice and regular line? Medical providers are also common businesses that insist on using SMS for 2FA and they use the same number for appointment reminders and customer service calls.

I’m still trying to figure out my phone number strategy. At this point, I have my main mobile line that I’ve had for 20+ years and a Google Voice number that I’ve been using for 4 years. I would assume both numbers have been linked to my identity a thousand times and are posted on data broker websites and the dark web.

I have a friend who did this and when the number wasn’t used for a while it got recycled into the pool for new numbers to be given out to other people. She wasn’t able to 2FA anymore and had to sort it out with a number of different services. I don’t know if there was credit on the account or not. Presumably there would have been some small amount left (cents) given the mobile provider.

First, check whether your banks offer an authenticator app (TOTP) or a security key. Both are stronger than SMS and don’t need a phone number at all. If they insist on SMS or a voice call, a dedicated prepaid line used only for banking is a sensible choice. Just know that once you give it to the bank it’s tied to your identity, at least for them, so I’d keep it separate from your emergency line. Whatever number you use, ask the carrier to add a port-out/SIM PIN to protect against SIM-swap attacks.

The first time you give someone, even a bank, that phone number, it stops being anonymous. Banks can and do report that as part of KYC.

Any 2FA that relies on a mobile phone is insecure simply because it’s not hard for someone to do a SIM swap attack. Not that it’s likely you’re a target for that, it’s typically people flaunting big crypto wallets on Twitter. Still, it’s an attack vector. As @roc mentions, Google Voice is more resistant to a SIM swap attack, if you bank requires a phone-based 2FA system (mine does, and I hate it).

On top of the fact that if you forget to load credit, lose the phone or it gets stolen, or maybe the carrier just has a whoopsie and cancels your number, your 2FA number is gone. Carriers will re-assign the number after 90 days usually, so you’re always about 120 days away from a stranger having your 2FA number.

Using a 2FA app or physical key is usually the best option - I prefer 2FA apps because you can back up the keys and move them between devices. So if your phone gets stolen, you take your backup keys and put them on a new phone.