Encrypted Solutions for Nextcloud?

I am finally experimenting with Nextcloud for the first time. I use my GOS phone regularly and need solutions that work on Android as well as Linux. Are there any good options for encrypting Nextcloud? I’ve seen the warnings about not using the built in E2EE. Are those still valid? It seems like Crptomator is not a workable solution to this on Android. Are there any trusted options? Is the only way to use Nextcloud in a private way pretty much to host it yourself? It seems like even a VPS would be kind of sketchy if you had sensitive data.

Honestly, there’s no good options to have your data in nextcloud be encrypted.
There’s server side encryption that you could enable, but that’s also less than ideal because the server has the keys.

Honestly if you’re using nextcloud you should trust yourself to keep the data on it safe :winking_face_with_tongue:

It seems like Crptomator is not a workable solution to this on Android.

Cryptomator on Android works with WebDAV, and so does Nextcloud. Cryptomator is probably the best multiplatform option with a good phone app that we have. There are also DroidFS and a lot of CLI tools that will be compatible with Linux.

It seems like even a VPS would be kind of sketchy if you had sensitive data.

If we trust the encryption tool, we don’t care much about the storage provider - if we talk about the data itself. Whether we trust them or not, they supposedly can’t bypass the encryption. So a local machine, a VPS, Google Drive, or just posting the encrypted blob on a forum is theoretically the same. So I’d check speed and stability first, then security, then privacy policy if it does matter for you.

Yes, I know that Cryptomator technically integrates with Nextcloud, but the integration basically just works to encrypt a vault on your Nextcloud storage. For anything except an encrypted drive, it seems like that functionality is lacking. There isn’t a way to work with your Cryptomator files within Nextcloud, and if I just wanted a drive there are much better options than Nextcloud.

A lot of the other things you might wanna sync with nextcloud are quite hard to have encrypted because they’re old legacy protocols. Like caldav, carddav and such.

I haven’t found any E2EE solution for Nextcloud with good enough usability over the years. Thankfully there have been multiple competitors rising in the E2EE cloud space, like Peergos, Proton, Filen and others, so the situation is a lot better then a few years ago.

Not sure if this counts, but Super Productivity (the task manager app) lets you do encrypted sync to your own cloud storage and Nextcloud is one of the options.