Your email address is exposed! In this video we break down the best tools for protecting your email address and rank them from S-tier to F-tier. How did your favorite email aliasing tool stack up?
You’re doing a great job with these videos!
Some stuff that wasn’t mentioned:
Microsoft Outlook (mail service)
Absolutely not reccomending for obvious privacy reasons, but you can create 10 Outlook.com account aliases using on their free tier. They all function as alternative full featured email addresses that go to the same Outlook mailbox and also function as alternative Microsoft login usernames to the same account.
I’m only mentioning this because Gmail’s pathetic + aliasing feature is always talked about as a mainstream option even though Outlook has a much better built-in, completely free, aliasing option.
Ignoring the obvious privacy sacrifices of trusting Microsoft with your email, the Outlook aliases are more competitive than other aliasing services as these are 10, full featured email addresses. Most free tiers and even some paid options aren’t this generous.
Outlook also supports custom domains in their paid tier. I’m not sure if you can send emails from an alias through a third-party email client, but you definitely can receive them just fine. Everything works normally using official Outlook clients (web, desktop, Mobile). If someone already trusts Outlook (even if they shouldn’t), this also eliminates having to trust another third party or having to create additional accounts to have to manage.
Fastmail
Fastmail was also skipped over. They support both email aliases and a built-in Masked Email service that are included in their email subscription. They are also of the the more affordable options outside of “free” big tech services and the bundled aliasing/masked email features make it an even better deal. Similar to Outlook, the bundled email eliminates the need to have to trust another party with your emails. They also support custom domains.
Similar to duckduckgo, they do not have a hard limit on masked emails, but they do have an undisclosed temporary limit on how many masked emails you can create per day, likely to stop abuse. It should reset the next day or so.
DuckDuckGo
You do not need to use the DuckDuckGo Browser or Extension to generate new aliases.
You can import your API token into Bitwarden and then generate new ones through that just as easily as any other other supported aliasing service. You just have to dig through developer tools one time in your browser to grab your API token. Assuming you make sure to save it somewhere safe (such as making an entry in Bitwarden), you shouldn’t have to do this more than once. You do have to re-import the token on each new Bitwarden client, so I’d reccomended making a Bitwarden entry for it for easy access.
There is also the third-party Quacky client for managing your duckduckgo aliases if you want more control than you get officially.
Regarding Vendor Lock-In
Since this video talked about vendor lock-in, I think it would be helpful to explain when you should expect to lose access to your email addresses as each service can do things differently.
One of the biggest selling points of SimpleLogin/Proton Pass aliases is that you get to keep existing aliases even after your subscription ends.
For most providers, this is not the case. Even Proton’s additional protonmail.com, proton.me, and pm.me addresses will disappear after you stop paying for premium Proton Mail.
Unless addy.io changed their policies recently, they will remove access to your shared domain aliases after your subscription ends.
Unless explicitly mentioned that you will get to keep your aliases, such as how SimpleLogin promises, the next best way to likely hold onto your email address is if the email address is supported in their free tier. Proton offers a free tier with a single proton domain, which is why you get to hold onto that after your paid proton mail subscription ends. But for services that do not have a free tier at all, you should expect to lose your shared email address completely unless you use a custom domain. Though this comes with privacy tradeoffs.
I’m going to make a separate post about my feelings toward custom domains for emails since it will be too off topic.
ooft D tier
ah well that’s fair (on email aliasing specifically)
Like the terminator, we’ll be back
We’re working both on official email aliasing and BYOD and more. We’ll try again again next year. fwiw we’re on both Windows and MacOS so you can go biiiig screen.
Good review video ![]()
Interesting video.
ADDY (2:06)
I’m glad you changed your mind about Addy. It should definitely be in the S tier. It’s the only alias provider that allows anonymous payments with no limitations which makes you harder to track. Addy also allows you to have multiple aliases (at least 3) for the same third party website, unlike SimpleLogin and Proton Pass.
The only features I wish Addy had are:
- The ability to choose our aliases before they are created.
- The ability to create our own prefixes.
These are two features that Proton Pass has, that I would really appreciate.
I often like to use initials as a prefix, and like to use suffixes that sound like they could be names.
instead of:
eg: redesign.greediness123@addy.io
SIMPLE LOGIN (4:03):
I would have probably put SimpleLogin in the A tier, because they only allow one alias per third party website, and although they accept anonymous payments via their gift card that you can purchase from the Proxy Store, it has limitations. They can only be used on free accounts, and you can’t top up more than one gift card on the same account, which means you can’t anonymously credit your account in advance.
I use virtual credit cards (VCCs) for everything, and for my yearly subscriptions, I tend to freeze my VCC after I renewed my subscription. This means I have to remember to unfreeze it right before the next billing cycle and I can sometimes forget. This is why I appreciate Addy & Tuta for letting me top up my accounts with credit in advance completely anonymously.
NO MENTION OF PROTON PASS?
I am surprised that there was no mention of it as an alias provider, but as I keep reminding people, Proton Pass is a separate product from SimpleLogin, even if they are bundled together, and the former is partially built on the infrastructure of the latter. They have separate subscriptions and hence are different products. Their aliases are for the most part, managed separately. I myself do not use SimpleLogin, but I use Proton Pass.
I would rank Proton Pass in the A tier, but I would probably rank it slightly lower than SL, because they have even more limitations on anonymous payments. I am currently unable to pay for my Proton Pass Plus subscription anonymously because of those limitations. They also only allow one alias per third party domain.
ICLOUD: HIDE MY EMAIL (10:15)
The simple fact that Apple’s HideMyEmail requires an Apple account instantly puts it in the B tier for me, if not lower, because you become easy to track via Apple. First, your location will be known because Apple requires that you select a country. Secondly, most people’s Apple accounts have their real name and address, which are other identifiers. I also believe that they require a phone number.
I have never tried creating an anonymous Apple account with a fake name and address, but I would not be suprised if it was harder today. Especially with the many countries requiring ID verification.
What I have tried however, is replacing my Apple account’s email from a Gmail address to a Proton Pass alias. Out of concern that I could potentially be locked out, I used a Proton Pass alias as my default address for my Apple account, and kept my Gmail as a secondary address.
I was right to do that because multiple times in the past I have tried logging into my Apple account with my Proton Pass alias, and it failed. When I tried again with my Gmail, it worked. In recent times, I have been able to log into my Apple account with my Proton Pass alias. However, because of what happened before, I am not willing to take the risk of removing my Gmail as a secondary address.
DUCK DUCK GO (7:32)
I would put DDG at the top of the B tier. I use it frequently, and I thank @Omar for introducing me to Qwacky a couple of months ago. I love that all of DDG’s aliases are free. I hope it stays that way. If they ever introduce a paid tier, I hope they don’t take away all the features that are currently free.
PROTON & TUTA MAIL (16:57)
I wouldn’t have included them on this list. Even though they both promote their additional email addresses as aliases, I disagree with this label because they have so many limits.
Their highest paid tiers only allows for 15 addresses. Moreover, those addresses cannot be easily deleted. Proton only allows you to delete one address per year. So if you have 10 addresses under the same account and wish to delete 5 today, you can’t. You will have to wait 5 years.
I don’t quite remember what the ToS are with Tuta. I believe that either you cannot delete your addresses, or if you can, you cannot replace them with new ones. So if you have 15 Tuta addresses, which is the max you can have, and wish to delete 5, you will not be able to replace those 5 addresses. As far as Tuta is concerned, you are still using 15 out of your 15 allowed addresses. Not 10 out of 15.
DISPOSABLE EMAIL (20:40)
I don’t understand the distinction between an alias and a disposable email. To me they are the same thing, because an alias is an email address I can delete easily, i.e., it’s disposable. If I can’t delete an address easily, it is not an alias.
It would seem that @nateb is defining disposable email addresses as addresses that are then reused by other people. In other words, many people across time and space use the same address, just never at the same time. If that is everyone’s general understanding, then I get it. But I know for a fact that is not the case.
Other companies that don’t like you using an Addy or SL alias will describe them as disposable addresses. Moreover, alias providers like Proton/SimpleLogin describe the addresses of other email and alias providers as disposable addresses when they have the exact same business model as them.
If any company can unfairly label email and alias providers as disposable and block them as a result, even though PG and the rest of us consider them authentic emails and aliases, then it’s super easy to muddy the definition.
But as I said, to me, an alias that cannot easily be deleted is not really an alias, which is also why I don’t consider Proton and Tuta mail addresses as aliases, because deleting them is not as simple as deleting an Addy or SL alias.
Duckduckgo is S if you already use bitwarden or vaultwarden and import your API key. You could also use desktop bitwarden instead of an extension, even if you don’t use it for passwords.
That’s a highly specific scenario that most won’t pull off, but it is pretty great. I have one duckduckgo email I’ve used a lot for communications and it works well even using it like a primary email. If I have to give an email to someone in person, that’s the one I go with.
I feel like Protonmail should be combined with SimpleLogin, because on their tier plans, like Proton Duo, or the family plans, you end up with Protonpass/SimpleLogin and Protonmail.
Combined you can create unlimited number of email aliases.
I didn’t mention StartMail because I am not particularly a fan. I’ve only used StartPage an eternity ago. However, I just heard from a friend who uses StartMail that you can send encrypted emails with their aliases.
Can someone else confirm if this is true?
If it is Proton Pass, Simple Login, and Addy should copy that feature.
I don’t know if we agree on this, but I have always felt from the moment Proton Pass launched that Proton Mail Plus should come with Proton Pass Plus at no extra cost. However, I am guessing you are referring to a special-priced bundle?
Yes, I’m talking about the paid plans. Proton has a bunch of individual application and bundles, and I cant guarantee that all of them have access to unlimited email aliases. Their website isnt the clearest about it. Especially with a couple of their single product paid plans. But I know Proton Duo has it. The family plans and business plans seem to have it as well.
I would think that most people who have a paid plan and would have unlimited aliases.
We’ve got 300-400+ individual email aliases with no limit that I know of.
I think that bundle is one of the biggest strengths of Proton as a whole. I doubt (but could be wrong) many people buy just a single product.
With addy.io you can send encrypted emails using your pgp key.
Also it has various options for alias formats including creating random names like brian.king567@addy.io. if I’m signing up for a service I use the name in the details instead of my own. Confuses the postman sometimes ![]()
You can also use “custom” to specify the bit before the first “.” Eg purple.mhskk555@addy.io
I think there’s a misunderstanding. If by “bundled subscription” you mean paying for multiple Proton services under a single subscription, there is only one option for individuals, and that is Proton Unlimited, which is their most expensive individual subscription. There is no bundle for those who just want to pay for 2 Proton services, such as Proton Pass Plus and Proton VPN Plus.
Moreover, and most importantly, Proton doesn’t allow multiple subscriptions under the same account. If I just want to pay for Proton Pass Plus and Proton Mail Plus under the same account, Proton won’t allow it. I know this because I’m in this exact situation and have been for years!
I had Proton Mail Plus for years, and when Proton Pass launched, I wanted to subscribe to Proton Pass Plus with my Proton Mail Plus account, but they wouldn’t let me. I had to create a second separate Proton account, which is very frustrating.
If you already pay for one Proton service, Proton will not allow you to pay for another service with the same account. They force you to choose between paying for a single product or paying for Proton Unlimited, which to me qualifies as both enshittification and a dark pattern.
It is only recently with the launch of Lumo that Proton has introduced add-ons, because they do not want to include Lumo in Proton Unlimited, nor do they want to increase the price of it. But add-ons are only for Lumo. Not for Proton Pass, Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Drive, etc…
I didn’t realize that. Thank you for letting me know.
OMG, you’re right! I did not know that. I just tested it and this is fantastic news!
That being said, I would still appreciate the flexibility that Proton Pass offers in Addy. I love that Addy can create random male and female names for you, but I like to use gender neutral names to further protect my privacy. And I prefer to choose those names.
I truly appreciate this feature, but I would prefer that the random characters added by Addy be exclusively numbers, otherwise it looks weird.
All this is really cool, but I would still like the flexibility that Proton Pass offer on top of Addy’s current offering.
I agree about using a fresh email for contacting CS, especially where the account email is used as the login Id, something which is way too common giving its obvious security compromise. I have accounts like this where the only way to change email address is to email customer support
. I sometimes wonder if these organisations have any actual it staff ![]()
I’m curious about the comment about gender neutral names, how do they enhance privacy/security?
If I’m contacting a company anonymously, 99.99% of the time, they don’t need to know what my gender is. I also think we all have biases, and that people make assumptions about both men and women when interacting with them online, so I’d rather it not be explicitly known.
Thus could become a very deep debate
. Keeping it simple I don’t only use aliases that match my gender, in fact I tend towards not.
However gender neutral names would be a cool addition to addy.io I think I will make a suggestion for it to be added.
People reacting differently to men and women shouldn’t be much of a debate. People will react differently even if you are a man with a female avatar in a game.
I don’t mind customer support knowing, but I do usually try to make my gender non-obvious on forums and such. I’ve mentioned it before on here when it was relevant, but my username on here is purposefully non-revealing.
I hear you. But I’d rather they not know my gender rather than pretend I’m a man if I’m a woman or vice versa. And to be clear, I’m not saying Addy should explicitly support gender-neutral names. Just allowing me to make up my own prefix, and chossing my own suffix before its created like Proton would solve that.
As in gender isn’t binary.
I can’t find any references to the aliasing advances made in proton pass vs Simplelogin. I have a Simplelogin account and its way lighter in options than Addy.io. Could you provide a link, I am very interested to learn more about it.
I’m not sure I understand. What exactly are you asking for? How to choose your alias in Proton Pass?
Specifically the things that can’t be done in addy